Skip to content
Seagry Consultancy
Menu

Common purpose / Safety systems

Regulation and oversight

Regulators are found to have accepted assurance, missed poor care, or overlapped with each other. Dash asked for a simpler landscape. Thirlwall and Amos asked for inspections that test real safety.

34 reviews · 39 recommendations

Reviews, most recent first

  1. 2026
    Amos maternity investigation

    Baroness Valerie Amos

  2. 2026
    HSSIB advice and guidance

    Health Services Safety Investigations Body

  3. 2026
    Thirlwall Inquiry

    Lady Justice Thirlwall

  4. 2025
    10 Year Health Plan

    Department of Health and Social Care

  5. 2025
  6. 2025
  7. 2024
    Dash review of CQC

    Dr Penny Dash

  8. 2024
    Shanley review, Edenfield

    Professor Oliver Shanley

  9. 2023
    Hewitt review

    Rt Hon Patricia Hewitt

  10. 2022
    East Kent maternity

    Dr Bill Kirkup

  11. 2022
    Neurology Inquiry (Watt)

    Brett Lockhart KC

  12. 2020
    Cumberlege review

    Baroness Cumberlege

  13. 2020
    Paterson Inquiry

    Rt Revd Graham James

  14. 2019
    Kark review

    Tom Kark KC

  15. 2019
    Richards screening review

    Professor Sir Mike Richards

  16. 2018
    Gosport

    Bishop James Jones

  17. 2018
  18. 2018
    Williams review

    Professor Sir Norman Williams

  19. 2015
    Freedom to Speak Up

    Sir Robert Francis KC

  20. 2015
    Morecambe Bay

    Dr Bill Kirkup

  21. 2015
    Rose review

    Lord Rose

  22. 2015
    Savile NHS lessons

    Kate Lampard and Ed Marsden

  23. 2013
    Cavendish review

    Baroness Cavendish

  24. 2013
    Clwyd-Hart review

    Rt Hon Ann Clwyd MP and Professor Tricia Hart

  25. 2013
    Francis public inquiry

    Sir Robert Francis KC

  26. 2013
    Keogh review

    Sir Bruce Keogh

  27. 2012
    Winterbourne View

    Department of Health

  28. 2011
    Munro review

    Professor Eileen Munro

  29. 2008
    Darzi review 2008

    Lord Darzi of Denham

  30. 2005
    Kerr/Haslam

    Nigel Pleming KC

  31. 2005
    Shipman Inquiry

    Dame Janet Smith

  32. 2003
  33. 2001
    Alder Hey (Redfern)

    Michael Redfern KC

  34. 2001
    Bristol Royal Infirmary

    Professor Sir Ian Kennedy

What they asked for

  1. Amos maternity investigation2026Awaiting response

    Create a specialist approach to regulating maternity and neonatal services, with clinicians involved, rather than a generic inspection model.

    NHS England, DHSC and CQC

  2. HSSIB advice and guidance2026Awaiting response

    NHS England and the Department of Health and Social Care should rapidly evaluate advice-and-guidance processes. Patient Safety Learning read this as something to finish before further expansion.

    NHS England and DHSC

  3. Thirlwall Inquiry2026Awaiting response

    Create a panel of independent clinical experts who can be sent quickly when harm by an individual is suspected.

    DHSC

  4. Thirlwall Inquiry2026Awaiting response

    Give medical examiners a clear neonatal checklist, and review whether their funding is adequate in 2027.

    National Medical Examiner and DHSC

  5. Thirlwall Inquiry2026Awaiting response

    Bar unfit managers from September 2027, review that scheme in 2030, and aim for full statutory regulation by 2032. Senior moves should not be used to hide conduct or capability problems.

    DHSC and NHS England

  6. Thirlwall Inquiry2026Awaiting response

    Inspect hospital departments without notice, with practising specialists on the team, and test whether patients are safe rather than whether a policy exists.

    CQC

  7. Thirlwall Inquiry2026Awaiting response

    Have the Health and Social Care Committee examine CQC's performance regularly.

    Parliament

  8. Thirlwall Inquiry2026Awaiting response

    Ask the National Audit Office to audit whether statutory inquiry recommendations are implemented, starting by September 2027.

    Government and the National Audit Office

  9. 10 Year Health Plan2025In progress

    Publish quality information, including league tables, so people can see how services compare.

    NHS England

  10. Keep rebuilding CQC as the principal quality regulator, with sector-specific assessment and a harder look at boards.

    CQC

  11. Keep HSSIB as a specialist investigation function, hosted inside CQC, with its independence from providers protected.

    DHSC

  12. Put accountability for the quality of care back onto commissioners and providers.

    ICBs and providers

  13. Dash review of CQC2024In progress

    Rebuild CQC's assessment approach and its technology, with clinical expertise back in inspection.

    CQC and DHSC

  14. Hewitt review2023Partly done

    Reduce the number of national targets and judge systems on outcomes, including prevention.

    Government and NHS England

  15. East Kent maternity2022Not implemented

    Stop commissioning new recommendation lists as a substitute for implementing the old ones.

    Government and NHS England

  16. Cumberlege review2020Accepted

    Appoint a Patient Safety Commissioner.

    Government

  17. Cumberlege review2020Partly done

    Reform the MHRA so that it looks harder for harm after a product is in use, with patients in the work.

    MHRA

  18. Paterson Inquiry2020Partly done

    Make multidisciplinary team discussion a real check on individual practice, including in the private sector.

    NHS and independent providers

  19. Paterson Inquiry2020Partly done

    Close the indemnity gap so private patients are not left without a route to compensation.

    Government

  20. Kark review2019Not implemented

    Give a body the power to disbar directors who are not fit.

    Government

  21. Give staff an external route when the trust itself is the problem.

    NHS England

  22. Williams review2018Partly done

    Improve the quality of expert advice to coroners and prosecutors in healthcare cases.

    Government

  23. Freedom to Speak Up2015Partly done

    Put a Freedom to Speak Up guardian in every NHS organisation, with a national office to support the role.

    NHS and government

  24. Morecambe Bay2015Partly done

    Refer professional failures to the relevant regulators.

    Trusts and regulators

  25. Rose review2015Not implemented

    Simplify the instructions the centre sends to trusts so leaders can lead.

    Department of Health and NHS England

  26. Savile NHS lessons2015Partly done

    Apply safeguarding rules to volunteers, celebrities and anyone else with access to patients.

    NHS trusts

  27. Cavendish review2013Partly done

    Be clearer about delegation and the boundary between registered and support roles.

    Employers and regulators

  28. Clwyd-Hart review2013Partly done

    Improve advocacy and the speed of the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman route.

    Government

  29. Francis public inquiry2013Partly done

    Set fundamental standards of care and make serious failure enforceable.

    Government and CQC

  30. Keogh review2013Partly done

    Put trusts with worrying mortality onto an urgent support and improvement footing.

    NHS England and regulators

  31. Winterbourne View2012Partly done

    Strengthen inspection of learning-disability inpatient units, including unannounced visits.

    Care Quality Commission

  32. Darzi review 20082008Partly done

    Put quality accounts, clinical dashboards and NICE quality standards into routine use.

    NHS

  33. Kerr/Haslam2005Partly done

    Take complaints of sexual misconduct by clinicians seriously and investigate them independently of the team.

    NHS employers and regulators

  34. Kerr/Haslam2005Partly done

    Improve information sharing when a clinician moves, so concerns are not left behind.

    Employers

  35. Shipman Inquiry2005Partly done

    Reform death certification so that deaths are scrutinised by someone independent of the doctor.

    Government

  36. Shipman Inquiry2005Accepted

    Revalidate doctors so that a licence to practise is not held for life without check.

    Professional regulators

  37. Require explicit consent for the retention and use of tissue after death.

    Government

  38. Publish comparable outcomes and act when a service is an outlier.

    NHS and regulators

  39. Regulate the quality of the service, not only the conduct of individual professionals.

    Government